Breach of Enterprise Agreement
Feeling Lost and Alone After a Breach of Your Enterprise Agreement?
What Exactly is an Enterprise Agreement?
Is Your Employer Holding Up Their End of the Bargain?
An enterprise agreement is an agreement made between an employer and its employees and approved by the Fair Work Commission. It sets pay and conditions for the employees it covers and is different from an individual employment contract, including how it is enforced under the Fair Work Act 2009. Depending on the workplace, an enterprise agreement can cover pay rates, hours, leave, consultation requirements, redundancy and other conditions, while the National Employment Standards continue to provide minimum entitlements.
These agreements are negotiated between your employer and employees (often represented by unions), with the Fair Work Commission ultimately approving them. This process aims to create a balanced and mutually beneficial framework for both parties.
However, even with a detailed enterprise agreement in place, breaches can still occur. This happens when your employer fails to uphold their obligations as outlined in the agreement, potentially leaving you feeling vulnerable and exploited. Section 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 is the key provision. It states that a person must not contravene the terms of an enterprise agreement. A contravention is a civil remedy provision, which means a court can impose a penalty where a breach is established. This is different from an ordinary contractual dispute at work.
What Does an Enterprise Agreement Cover?
Your regular hours of work, breaks, rostering arrangements, and any flexibility around working from home or adjusting your schedule are often clearly defined within the agreement.
From annual leave and sick leave to parental leave and compassionate leave, your agreement outlines how much leave you can take and the process for requesting it, helping you maintain a healthy work-life balance.
Your enterprise agreement may include provisions around job security, consultation processes for any significant workplace changes, and entitlements to redundancy pay if your role is made redundant, providing a safety net for your future.
A clear process for resolving workplace disputes is usually outlined in the agreement, including steps for raising grievances, mediation, and escalation procedures, promoting a fair and transparent workplace.
Who We Are
Sibley Lawyers is a boutique law firm with a distinct focus on criminal and employment law. We believe in providing specialist advocacy and achieving the best possible outcomes for our clients. Our team comprises experienced lawyers and former barristers with a deep understanding of the legal system and a passion for justice.
We pride ourselves on our commitment to excellence, personalised service, and unwavering dedication to protecting our clients’ rights. Whether you’re facing a criminal charge or a workplace dispute, we’ll be by your side, providing expert guidance and tenacious representation every step of the way.
What a Breach of an Enterprise Agreement Can Cost an Employer
Because section 50 is a civil remedy provision, a court can impose a penalty on an employer in addition to ordering payment of any amount owed. The maximum penalty is calculated in penalty units. For conduct on or after 1 July 2026, a Commonwealth penalty unit is $364. An ordinary contravention of an enterprise agreement carries 60 penalty units, with the maximum amount depending on who committed the contravention.
These maximums apply to contraventions, not to the claim as a whole. The number of contraventions is not determined simply by counting each employee or pay period affected. Under the Fair Work Act, multiple breaches that arise from the same course of conduct may be treated as a single contravention. The maximum penalty will therefore depend on the circumstances of the matter.
| Who contravened | Maximum penalty, ordinary contravention | Maximum penalty, serious contravention |
|---|---|---|
| An individual | $21,840 | $218,400 |
| An employer with fewer than 15 employees | $109,200 | $1,092,000 |
| An employer with 15 or more employees | $546,000 | $5,460,000 |
Serious Contraventions
A contravention is serious where the employer knew it was contravening the law or was reckless as to whether a contravention would occur. The Fair Work Ombudsman identifies enterprise agreements as one of the instruments to which the higher serious-contravention penalties can apply. The increased penalties and higher multiplier for larger employers took effect on 1 January 2025. Intentional underpayment can also amount to a criminal offence for conduct from 1 January 2025, with separate penalties that can include imprisonment and a fine.
If Your Employer's Records Do Not Add Up
If an employer has failed to meet its record-keeping or pay slip obligations without a reasonable excuse, a reverse onus of proof can apply in a wage claim, including a claim under an enterprise agreement. In practical terms, the employer may have to disprove an allegation about what the employee was paid rather than leaving the employee to prove it from incomplete records. Missing or poor records do not necessarily prevent an employee from pursuing a claim.
The Ripple Effect of a Breach: Understanding the Consequences
A breach of your enterprise agreement can have far-reaching consequences that extend beyond the immediate situation. It’s not just about a financial loss or a single incident; it can create a ripple effect impacting your emotional well-being, career trajectory, and even the overall workplace environment.
Here’s a closer look at how a breach can affect both employees and employers:
Financial Instability
Underpayment, denied entitlements, or incorrect superannuation contributions can create significant financial strain and anxiety.
Emotional and Psychological Impact
Experiencing unfair treatment, bullying, or harassment can lead to stress, anxiety, and even depression, affecting your overall well-being.
Damaged Career Prospects
An unfair dismissal or disciplinary action on your record can create obstacles in your career path and limit future opportunities.
Erosion of Trust
A breach can severely damage the trust between you and your employer, creating a hostile and uncomfortable work environment.
Legal Challenges and Compensation
Employees can take legal action seeking compensation for lost wages, denied entitlements, or emotional distress.
What are you entitled to at work?
Understanding Your Entitlements
Navigating the world of employment law and understanding your entitlements can feel like deciphering a complex code. However, it’s crucial to be aware of your rights as an employee, as this knowledge empowers you to identify potential breaches and advocate for fair treatment in your workplace.
Your entitlements stem from a combination of sources, including the National Employment Standards (NES), any relevant awards or enterprise agreements, and your individual employment contract. The NES sets the minimum standards for all employees in Australia, covering areas like maximum weekly hours, leave entitlements, and termination notice periods.
Awards are industry-specific documents that outline minimum pay rates and conditions for specific occupations. Enterprise agreements, as we’ve discussed, are tailored agreements negotiated between employers and employees, often providing terms and conditions that are more generous than the award or NES. Finally, your individual employment contract may contain specific entitlements or clauses relevant to your role.
Enterprise Agreement, Award or Employment Contract: Which One Covers You?
| Instrument | What it is | If it is breached |
|---|---|---|
| Enterprise agreement | A collective agreement for a workplace or group of employees, approved by the Fair Work Commission | A court can impose a penalty under section 50 and order the money owed to be paid |
| Modern award | An industry or occupation-wide safety net of minimum pay and conditions | A court can impose a penalty and order the money owed to be paid |
| Individual employment contract | The agreement between you and your employer alone | A claim for damages at common law, not a penalty |
Employees are often unsure whether an enterprise agreement, modern award or individual employment contract applies to their issue. That distinction matters because it affects the type of claim that may be available if an entitlement has been breached.
The distinction between these instruments matters. An individual employment contract cannot remove minimum entitlements that apply under an enterprise agreement, modern award or the National Employment Standards. If the issue concerns a term of your individual contract rather than a collective instrument, such as notice, a restraint of trade clause or another contractual obligation, it may be a different type of claim. Our employment contract law page explains those disputes in more detail. If you are unsure which instrument applies, bring your recent payslips and any agreement or contract you have been given to your first consultation so the relevant terms can be identified.
Where a Breach of Enterprise Agreement Claim Goes
A breach of enterprise agreement can involve the Fair Work Commission, a court, or both at different stages. Which forum is appropriate depends on the agreement, the type of breach and the outcome being sought.
The Fair Work Commission, Under Your Agreement's Dispute Resolution Term
Every enterprise agreement must contain a dispute resolution term. The Fair Work Commission cannot approve an agreement without one. The term must set out a process for the Commission or another independent person to deal with disputes about the agreement and must allow employees to be represented. In many matters, that dispute process is the first place to look before court proceedings are considered.
The Fair Work Commission can only exercise the powers given to it by the dispute resolution term in the enterprise agreement. It can arbitrate, meaning make a decision on the dispute, only where the parties have agreed in the term that it may do so. Depending on the agreement, the Commission may instead mediate, conciliate, provide advice or make a recommendation. The Commission is a tribunal and does not have the same enforcement powers as a court.
The Courts, For a Penalty and the Money Owed
A claim that an employer has contravened section 50 may be brought in the Federal Court, the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, or an eligible state or territory court. An employee can bring a claim, as can an employer, a union covered by the agreement or a Fair Work Inspector in the circumstances allowed by the Act. The court can order payment of amounts owed, impose a penalty and make other orders it considers appropriate.
For eligible Fair Work claims of $100,000 or less, the small claims procedure provides a more informal court process. Legal representation is generally restricted unless the Court gives permission.
How Long You Have
| Type of claim | Time limit |
|---|---|
| Recovering an entitlement under an enterprise agreement, including small claims | 6 years from the date of the contravention |
| Unfair dismissal | 21 days from the dismissal taking effect |
| General protections dismissal claim | 21 days from the dismissal taking effect |
The time limit depends on the type of claim being made. Some employment claims have much shorter deadlines than others.
The 21-day time limits for dismissal claims can only be extended in exceptional circumstances. If a breach of enterprise agreement is connected with the loss of your job, the 21-day dismissal deadline should be considered straight away rather than relying on the longer period that may apply to recovering money owed.
Is a Breach of Your Enterprise Agreement Affecting Your Well-being and Future?
Don’t try to navigate this complex legal landscape alone. Contact Sibley Lawyers today for a confidential consultation and let our experienced team guide you through the process. We’ll fight tirelessly to protect your rights and secure the best possible outcome for your situation.
Our Breach of Enterprise Agreement Services
At Sibley Lawyers, we understand that dealing with a breach of your enterprise agreement can be overwhelming. Our team of experienced employment lawyers is dedicated to providing clear, compassionate guidance and tenacious representation to help you navigate this challenging situation and secure the best possible outcome.
Unpaid Wages and Entitlements
We understand the financial and emotional stress caused by unpaid wages or missing entitlements. Our team meticulously reviews payslips, employment contracts, and enterprise agreements to identify any discrepancies and fight for the full recovery of what you’re owed. Whether it’s unpaid overtime, penalty rates, allowances, or superannuation contributions, we’ll work tirelessly to ensure you receive every dollar you’ve earned.
Unfair Dismissal
Losing your job unexpectedly can be devastating. If you believe your dismissal was unfair, unjust, or unlawful, we can help. We’ll examine the circumstances of your termination, advise you on your rights, and represent you in any legal proceedings to seek reinstatement or appropriate compensation for lost income and emotional distress.
Discrimination and Harassment
Everyone deserves a safe and respectful workplace free from discrimination, harassment, and bullying. If you’ve experienced unfair treatment based on your gender, race, age, disability, or any other protected attribute, we’ll help you understand your rights and take action. We’ll work to hold your employer accountable and seek appropriate remedies, including compensation and changes to workplace policies.
General Protections
The law protects employees from adverse action taken by their employer because they’ve exercised a workplace right, such as making a complaint, joining a union, or refusing to engage in unsafe work practices. We’ll help you understand your rights under the Fair Work Act’s general protections provisions and take action if you’ve been unfairly targeted for speaking up or standing up for your rights.
Redundancy
While redundancy can be a legitimate reason for job loss, employers must follow a fair and transparent process as outlined in the applicable award or enterprise agreement. We can help you understand your rights during a redundancy process, ensure you receive proper consultation and notice periods, and negotiate appropriate redundancy pay and entitlements.
How We Handle Your Breach of Enterprise Agreement Claim
Guiding You Towards Resolution
We understand that every situation is unique. That’s why we tailor our approach to your specific needs and circumstances, providing personalised guidance and support throughout your legal journey. Here’s an overview of our process:
Initial Consultation
We start with a confidential consultation to discuss your situation, gather information about the alleged breach, and answer any questions you may have.
Case Assessment
We thoroughly review your enterprise agreement, employment contract, payslips, and any other relevant documents to assess the strength of your claim.
Legal Advice and Strategy
Negotiation and Mediation
We attempt to reach a fair settlement through negotiation and mediation with your employer, aiming for an amicable resolution.
Legal Proceedings
If necessary, we’ll initiate legal proceedings and represent you in court, advocating for your rights and seeking the best possible outcome.
Ongoing Support
We provide continuous support and guidance throughout the process, keeping you informed and empowered every step of the way.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is an enterprise agreement legally binding?
An enterprise agreement is legally binding on the employers, employees and organisations it covers once it is in operation. Section 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 provides that a person must not contravene the terms of an enterprise agreement, and a breach can result in a court ordering payment of amounts owed and imposing a civil penalty. This gives an enterprise agreement a different legal status from an ordinary workplace policy or informal promise. Whether a particular obligation has been breached will depend on the wording of the agreement and the circumstances of the conduct.
What are the penalties for breaching an enterprise agreement?
The penalties for breaching an enterprise agreement depend on who committed the contravention, whether it was serious and, in some cases, the amount of any underpayment involved. For conduct on or after 1 July 2026, one ordinary contravention can attract a maximum penalty of $21,840 for an individual, $109,200 for a company with fewer than 15 employees, or $546,000 for a company with 15 or more employees. Serious contraventions can attract substantially higher maximum penalties where the person knowingly contravened the law or was reckless as to whether the contravention would occur. Multiple breaches can sometimes be treated as a single contravention where they arise from the same course of conduct, so the applicable maximum depends on the facts of the matter.
Can an enterprise agreement override the Fair Work Act?
An enterprise agreement cannot override the Fair Work Act 2009 or remove minimum entitlements provided by the National Employment Standards. The Fair Work Commission considers these statutory requirements when deciding whether to approve an enterprise agreement. An agreement can provide terms and conditions that are more beneficial than minimum statutory entitlements and may also operate alongside a modern award where relevant. If a term of an enterprise agreement conflicts with a requirement of the Fair Work Act, the legislation takes priority.
How do I know if my employer has breached my enterprise agreement?
You can identify a possible breach of your enterprise agreement by comparing the obligations in the agreement with what your employer has done in practice. Common issues can include pay below an agreed rate, unpaid overtime or penalty rates, incorrectly calculated leave, missed consultation requirements, incorrect redundancy entitlements or rostering arrangements that do not comply with the agreement. The wording of the particular clause matters, so the starting point is to obtain the enterprise agreement that applies to you and compare it with your payslips, rosters, correspondence and other relevant records. If an employer has failed to keep required employment records or payslips, the Fair Work Act can affect who bears the burden of proving what occurred in a wage-related claim.
How long do I have to make a claim for a breach of an enterprise agreement?
The time limit for making a claim involving a breach of an enterprise agreement depends on the type of claim you need to bring. A civil remedy proceeding to recover an entitlement under an enterprise agreement can generally be commenced within six years of the contravention. If the matter also involves dismissal, much shorter deadlines may apply, including 21 days for an unfair dismissal application or a general protections dismissal application. Extensions of those dismissal time limits are only available in limited circumstances, so a person who has lost their job should not rely on the longer six-year period that may apply to the underlying entitlement claim.
Do I have to go through my agreement’s dispute process before going to court?
Whether you must complete your enterprise agreement’s dispute process before starting court proceedings depends on the wording of the agreement and the type of claim being made. Every enterprise agreement must contain a dispute settlement term, and that process will usually set out the steps for dealing with disagreements about the agreement. The Fair Work Commission may be able to assist through mediation, conciliation, recommendations or arbitration where the agreement gives it that power, but its role is limited by the terms of the agreement. Because court enforcement rights and agreement-based dispute procedures do not operate identically, the dispute clause should be reviewed before deciding which process to use.
How much will it cost to run a breach of enterprise agreement claim?
The cost of running a breach of enterprise agreement claim depends on the forum, the amount in dispute and whether the matter resolves early or proceeds to a contested hearing. A dispute dealt with through an enterprise agreement’s dispute resolution procedure may involve lower legal costs than court proceedings, particularly where the matter resolves through conciliation or mediation. Claims of $100,000 or less may also be eligible for the Fair Work small claims procedure, which is designed to provide a more informal and accessible court process. For larger or more complex disputes, the likely cost will depend on the evidence required, the number of issues in dispute and how the other party responds, so the appropriate pathway should be assessed before significant costs are incurred.
These FAQs are general information only and do not constitute legal advice. The law is complex and fact-specific. You should seek independent legal advice for your particular situation.
Our goal is to help you achieve a fair and just resolution to your workplace dispute, allowing you to move forward with confidence and peace of mind.
But don't just take our word for it
Our Track Record Speaks for Itself
We don’t just promise results, we deliver them. We’ve secured acquittals, reduced charges, and protected the freedom and reputations of countless clients. But don’t just take our word for it. Read our client testimonials to see what our clients have to say about our dedication, expertise, and results.
FEATURED
KS Kieran Strongman
Justin Sibley gave me my life back. In 2020, my Ex-wife began a 3 year assailment where she weaponised the domestic violence system for the purpose of controlling a property settlement. Had it not been for Justin and his team, she may have succeeded. Justin expertly dismantled the web of lies that she spun through countless court appearances at multiple locations- Domestic violence applications and applications to vary that went all the way to trial, as well as a criminal charge. Throughout these 3 years of hell, Justin was a godsend- He was calm, confident, and extremely knowledgeable. After being shellshocked, panicked, and devastated that this was happening to me, Justin got my head straight and educated me on the process and how we would deal with it. From the early days I felt confident that justice would prevail with Justin on my side. From Justins early communications with Police prosecutions, to his expert cross examination of the complainant and witnesses in Court, not once did I feel I would get anything other than a desirable outcome. One of the most memorable experiences in my life was watching and listening to Justins cross examinations- The way he would slowly and subtly lock someone into a version of events or a lie, then some time later, absolutely dismantle it in a way they just could not see coming- It was an absolute pleasure to watch. Justin did such an impeccable job in handling my matters, that not only did we beat the 'balance of probabilities'- but Justin destroyed it- All DV matters against me were found to be frivolous and vexatious, and the Magistrate was scathing of the Police and the 'aggrieved'/complainant. Jutin didnt just win, he didnt show the allegations 'probably didnt happen'- He proved that every single one of them did NOT happen. I can not see how any solicitor could have done a better job or got a better outcome than Justin did- It was a resounding win, to the point where Justin had costs above the scale awarded in my favour. This is exceptionally rare in DV/civil matters, and was an outstanding result for me- I got my life back without the financial devastation so many suffer having to finance their defence in these type of matters. Justins comprehensive and absolute win in these DV matters echoed through to my criminal charge which dragged on after the DV matters were dismissed- Justin was successful in obtaining a very rare 'permanent stay' of proceedings, based on his resounding win and total dismantling of the DV allegations. If you're up against it, talk to Justin. It's not just a job for him- I truly felt that Justin had my back, believed in me, and wanted to help me. Thank you Justin.
MD Meah Davis
I cannot express enough gratitude for the exceptional work Justin and the team did during an extremely difficult time. From the very beginning, they were not only professional and knowledgeable, but also incredibly compassionate and understanding. Their expertise and strategic thinking resulted in the best possible outcome for my case, something I didn't think was achievable. They were always available to answer my questions, explain the legal process in a way I could understand, and made me feel supported every step of the way. I highly recommend them to anyone in need of a dedicated and skilled attorney.
TW Timothy Wyer
It's very rare, that you leave court with a smile on your face. Thank's to Justin and the team at Sibley Law. We got a win and some money back as well, I highly recommend them!
DS Dallas Spillane
Today I had Justin pull the best outcome one could imagine I'm at home tonight and at work tomorrow cause of his dedication to what he does and that got me the best outcome in court thank you Justin
KJ Kelly Jewell
Highly recommend Sibley's Lawyers. Extremely professional. Their communication is excellent. Very thorough in their approach and attention to detail.
MM Marama Montgomery
Justin, Nick, and the entire team at Sibley Lawyers were absolutely phenomenal in handling my legal matter. Their expertise, dedication, and professionalism made a challenging situation much more manageable. From the initial consultation to the resolution of my case, they provided unwavering support, guidance, and advocacy every step of the way. Not only were they highly knowledgeable in their field, but they also demonstrated genuine care and concern for my well-being throughout the process. They took the time to listen to my concerns, explain complex legal concepts in a clear and understandable manner, and always kept me informed and updated on the progress of my case. Their attention to detail, strategic approach, and relentless pursuit of justice yielded a favorable outcome that exceeded my expectations. I am immensely grateful for their hard work, diligence, and unwavering commitment to achieving the best possible result for me. I cannot recommend Justin, Nick, and the team at Sibley Lawyers highly enough. If you're in need of legal representation, look no further—they are truly exceptional. Thank you, Sibley Lawyers, for your outstanding service and support during a challenging time.
MH Mitch Hetherington
Highly recommended
CW Caelon Woodward
Good team, would recommend for stuff like speeding offences.
SC Sara Christofis
I highly recommend Justin and Nick and the team at Sibley Lawyers. From my initial consultation I felt comfortable. They were professional, approachable and were able to achieve a far better outcome at Court than I was expecting.
Other services
Legal Insights
Stay informed about the latest legal developments and gain valuable insights by reading our blog. We regularly publish articles on a variety of legal topics.
- Author assistant
- Published
- Author Justin Sibley
- Published
- Author Justin Sibley
- Published
- Author assistant
- Published
Worried About the Financial Impact of a Breach?
Dealing with a breach of enterprise agreement can be a daunting and stressful experience
Don’t let a breach of your enterprise agreement go unchallenged. Contact Sibley Lawyers today for a confidential consultation. Our team of experienced employment lawyers is ready to listen to your concerns, assess your situation, and provide expert guidance on the best course of action.
Join Our Mailing List
Sign up for our newsletter to receive updates on legal news, firm announcements, and helpful resources.